The truth will set you free. A subtext that is certainly relevant in Episodes three and four of BBC's miniseries, Les Miserables. After years of lying and hiding, Val Jean now holds a man's life in his hands. Javert in his own self-righteousness, believes himself to always be on the side of truth, regardless of who may be destroyed in the process. Both Fantine and her daughter, Cosette must painfully experience truth found in the darkest parts of humanity. Young Marius Pontmercy confronts his grandfather on his lifetime of lies toward his own father. The Thenardiers histories of deceit and lawlessness comes to an end, only to start again and becoming infinitely worse.
The truth is hard, painful, ugly and maybe at times, unjust. How does one judge what is truth and what is deception? And where is the line when it comes to life and death?
Episode Three
Upon finding out that a man assumed to be Prisoner 24601 has been arrested, Jean Valjean now has an escape. If this relatively obscure prisoner is proven to be him, then he can no longer live in fear of being discovered. He can no longer hide from Javert. He can finally be freed from all past imprisonment. And yet, he is a changed man. He dismissed Fantine for lying to him about her child and therefore, ruined her life. How can he stand by and let another pay for the mistakes of his own making? While this prisoner is by no means an innocent in the eyes of the law, in the eyes God, he is innocent of being Jean Valjean.
In an utter act of faith, Jean Valjean reveals himself to be prisoner 24601. Now he has literally put himself into Javert's grasp. Meanwhile, Fantine is dying in the infirmary, praying to see her daughter. Valjean has promised to reunite mother and daughter, but his decision to uncover his true self has put him back into the galleys of the prison ships. Fantine dies without her daughter, but Valjean promises that he will find Cosette and he will protect her from the world that destroyed her mother.
Two years later, Valjean has escaped from prison (although we're never told exactly how) and he makes good on his promise to find Fantine's daughter. He does find Cosette, in the worst conditions imaginable. The Thenardiers have abused Cosette to every possible degree. She is beaten for entertainment of the guests, given hard manual labor, dressed in rags, forbidden to talk or play and has increasingly no hope of future happiness. That changes when Valjean finds her in the forest and is incensed by her brutal treatment.
It doesn't take long for him to put Rosalie Thenardier in her place, demanding that Cosette play as a regular child while Madame Thenardier gets his food instead. He pays an exorbitant amount of money to secure Cosette's release from her abusers and threatens Thenardier when he goes too far. Things only get worse for the detestable family when they reach financial ruin and are left completely destitute.
The only person that is never too away from Valjean is Javert. Ever vigilant and consistent, Javert tracks down Valjean and Cosette in Paris where they have been hiding. Both of them have begun to develop a loving father/daughter relationship. Valjean teaches Cosette how to read and she impresses him with her wit and overwhelming sweetness; not to different from her mother. When this little happiness is threatened by Javert, Valjean and Cosette find shelter in a convent and all girl's school. They are finally safe.
For a while at least.
Episode Four
Nine or ten years later, Cosette has grown into a lovely young woman who is lively, vibrant and curious about the outside world. Having no family or money, Cosette has little chance of a proper marriage or a life in society. Her only option is to become a 'bride of Christ,' (a nun). Discontent with staying behind the walls of the nunnery for the rest of her life, she begs her father to leave, wanting to see the world for herself.
However, Valjean is hesitant to do so. He has seen the world and all its cruelty and unjustness and believes that Cosette is too fragile and innocent to understand it. Yet, even in spite of her past life with the Thenardiers, Cosette wants to believe that there is good and she wants to see that good for herself.
Valjean eventually agrees and purchases a small home for him and Cosette in the upper middle class section of Paris. To get there, though, they must pass through the worst parts of Paris' poverty stricken streets. Beggars, thieves, the sick and the dying are all there to greet Cosette on her first visit to the outside world.
As Cosette is getting introduced to outside Paris, young law student, Marius Pontmercy is introduced to some startling information about his own past. His whole life, he has been told by his grandfather that his own father was a traitor to France and a coward. Yet, he is told the truth by an elderly man in church and then proceeds to know more about the former Col. Pontmercy. Marius is outraged by his grandfather's lies and corruption and immediately leaves his once comfortable life. He ventures out into the lower echelons of Parisian society that are a stark contrast to his once well to do livings.
Marius comes into the company of several politically minded students, some more fiery than others. He also has the misfortune of renting a room next to the infamous Thenardier family who are strangling money from every person they meet. They use their two daughters, Eponine and Azelma in every way possible to lie and cheat strangers and other tenants. Meanwhile, their youngest son, Gavroche is left to fend for himself, but the charming little boy knows how to run the streets.
Eponine Thenardier, a raggedy and homely thief has taken an especial interest in the handsome law student. She is surprised by his genuine kindness even though he believes he is taken advantaged of. Her manipulative nature begins to wear away the more time she spends with Marius, but it's not long before his head is turned by a beautiful, golden haired angel walking in the Luxembourg Gardens with her guardian. Marius becomes besotted with the young girl named only Cosette, but her father is less than pleased.
Valjean is still trying to shield his daughter from the world, but Cosette just wants more. She is desperate to be a part of society, but her new home has become another prison and her father becoming more and more a jail keeper.
Things become even more strained when they cross paths with the Thenardiers again. Still holding a grudge toward Valjean for taking Cosette and blaming him for their financial losses, Thenardier plans on getting his revenge of Valjean once and for all. And unfortunately Marius is put right in the middle, having to choose between all the lies and the truth itself.
Good review! I think that I like this Marius more than in the musical. Not sure yet, though. Jean Valjean is the best! :)
ReplyDeleteThank you! I like this Marius as well. At first I was disappointed because I don't think he's that attractive, but the actor's ability to convey so much emotional conflict far outweighs his looks. And I love Jean Valjean! Dominic West is just incredible!
DeleteAhhh, I'll be really interested to see how this miniseries handles Cosette, Marius, and Eponine. Good review, once again! :)
ReplyDeleteSo far it's primarily been the early pre-Cosette interaction between Epoine and Marius. However, they have definitely put the love at first sight storyline in there. Cosette is confused, naive and innocent, but Marius...is actually quite humerous at times. He's so lost.
DeleteThank you! I'm hoping the reviews will encourage people to watch the series!
To offer a alternative view very badly so far, Cosette and Eponine seem to have been turned into marriagable blonde & white virgin/fuckable black & red haired whore love interests for a throughly unappealing Marius. Just my perspective.
DeleteThat’s what I always gathered from the story in the first place.
DeleteDidn't like this Marius. Not innocent enough, and looks too old for Cosette. WTF was with that strip tease scene. Why did they spend all that time on him as a child then skip his years in poverty. Strange.
ReplyDeleteWhy is everyone whining about the striptease scene? It wasn’t that terrible and as a Thenardier it fit Eponine’s manipulative character.
DeleteBecause Eponine isn't supposed to be sexy? She's described as ugly and unfeminine. Her situation is tragic, her function in the story is to be the mirror of what Cosette "could" have been. NOT to be a sexy love interest for Marius (who, as described in the book, would not be loving a striptease by some random beggar girl or really any girl, he's awkward and scared of them). Are other people complaining about it? Good, it was an awful scene.
ReplyDeleteOpps and forgot to add - Cosette is not blonde in the books and Eponine has pale skin, she's described as ghostly.
DeleteI never saw it as her trying to be sexy at all. She's behaving as a desperate young girl who is trying to get money. Fantine sold her hair and her two front teeth and the proceeded to prostitute herself for the same reason, not to be sexy. It was a 15 second scene that was awakening Marius' to the real world. How come no one is complaining about when she was in the red light district clearly doing other business?
DeleteCosette is frequently portrayed as a blonde in the plays and Eponine is usually portrayed by Asian or black women. So why should the miniseries be any different? I'm glad when the BBC puts diversity in their shows. And the appearances of both girls are pretty insignificant details to complain about.
It's all in the framing. Like I said, she's framed as a sexy femme fatale there to tease Marius rather than a tragic teenager. And representation is all well and good but shouldn't it matter WHAT is being represented? How come dark skinned girls never get to be the ingenue?
ReplyDeleteI don't care about the musical I just wanted a solid adaption of the book, this episode really threw me off tbh. :(
We have only just met her and there's still two more episodes left and plenty more of her story to tell. As far as representation, Eponine is usually the favored of the two girls, so I would figured people would be happy to have her being played by a dark skinned actress. I think the girl who plays Azelma is really pretty and would have made good Cosette.
DeleteI've never read the book...I tried, but it was just too much at the time. Given the size of the novel, it would be insurmountable to try and adapt the story in a way that will make everyone happy.
Literally no one wanted to see Marius licking his lips watching Eponine striptease. Except the creepy looking writer I guess.
Delete